The American Republican
What A Negroe's Life is Worth in Delaware

Transcription
What A Negro's Life is Worth in
Delaware.
An occurrence took place at Dover, Delaware,
last week, which shows what value is attached
to the life of a colored man by the old slave-
driving aristocrats of that State. Dr. West,
was tried at Dover for the murder of a negro
named Turner, who was in his employ. The
particulars of the killing are thus succinctly
furnished in an editorial article taken from
the Norristown Herald.
Not less remarkable than the crime itself,
was the verdict rendered by the “intelligent
jury” (!) to the West murder case at Dover,
Del.—“Not guilty, on the ground of self-
defence.” Now let us look briefly at this
“self-defence” farce. On the 2d of Decem-
ber last, a horrible murder was committed at
Dover, Del. Dr. Isaac C. West killed a harm-
less colored man named Henry Turner—in
self-defence, the jury say, although there was
nothing but the confession of the foiled mur-
derer upon which to base such a verdict.
After killing him, West cut off the hands of
his victim—in self-defence; then he severed
the head from the body—in self-defence; then
he amputated his feet—in self-defence; then
so fearful was he that the mutilated remains
of Turner would do him some bodily injury,
he skinned the body with a pocket knife—in
self-defence; then he attempted to burn the
skin while, with the intention of replacing it
on the body—in self defence! And now, as
West gazed upon the cut body of poor Turner,
he must have fancied that the corpse was about to spring upon him, for he returned to his bloody work and cut off several pieces of the body, and deposited them in various places along the railroad—in self-defence. And again, Turner must have assumed a threatening attitude, for the frightened Doctor set fire to the building, in hopes of obliterating all traces of his crime—in self-defence. He was occupied three days in attempting to get rid of the remains of his victim, before setting fire to his office by an explosion, and then left Dover—in self-defence, of course. The theory of this murder is, that West having his life heavily insured, wished to create the belief that it was himself, and not Turner, who was killed in his office, by the explosion of a certain gas he was known to have been manufacturing, and after his wife had recovered the insurance money, he would have made his existence known—if she was not in the plot—and enjoy the “spoils”—in self defence. This monstrous verdict means—if it means anything—that it is not a crime to “kill a nigger” in Dover. If the case had been reversed—Turner the culprit and West the victim—ten to one the murderer would have been strung up without the formula of a trial by judge and jury—in self-defence. West, however, has been rearrested on the charge of arson, and as that crime is met with capital punishment in Delaware it is to be hoped that he may be found guilty and executed—in self defence.
It is due to truth and public decency to say, that this monstrous verdict has caused profound disgust among the better portion of the citizens of Delaware, and the newspapers have not failed to denounce it in terms fitting its enormity and disgraceful character.
Newspaper Location












An article detailing the controversial acquittal of Dr. Issac C. West for the brutal murder and mutilation of Henry Turner, criticizing the justice system in Delaware.
Citations
The American Republican, "What A Negroe's Life is Worth in Delaware," 17 June 1873, p. 2; digital image, Newspapers.com (https://www.newspapers.com/article/the-american-republican-dr-issac-c-west/179907700/ : accessed 1 August 2026), clip page for Dr. Issac C West murder of Henry Turner Pt1 by user englishwalter.
What A Negroe's Life is Worth in Delaware. (1873, June 17). The American Republican, 2. https://www.newspapers.com/article/the-american-republican-dr-issac-c-west/179907700/
"What A Negroe's Life is Worth in Delaware." The American Republican, 17 June 1873, p. 2. Newspapers.com, https://www.newspapers.com/article/the-american-republican-dr-issac-c-west/179907700/.
"What A Negroe's Life is Worth in Delaware." The American Republican, June 17, 1873, 2. https://www.newspapers.com/article/the-american-republican-dr-issac-c-west/179907700/.