New York Daily Herald

West's Trial: The Closing Argument by Attorney General; The Judge's Charge

6/11/1873New York, New YorkAwaiting review Reconstruction (1865-1900) Lynching/Violence
Image
100%
West's Trial: The Closing Argument by Attorney General; The Judge's Charge 1

Transcription

Awaiting Review1 contributor
Denise Robles Read only

WEST'S TRIAL

Closing Argument by Attorney General Love

A Fearful Resume of the "Professor's" History

WHY HE BUTCHERED TURNER

A Medical Student Who Split Frogs on Sticks

Inordinate Love of Money, Ambition and Poverty

THE JUDGE'S CHARGE

Chief Justice Gilpin Crushing the Insanity Plea

RETIREMENT OF THE JURY

DOVER, Del., June 10, 1873
The curtain fell to-day. The drama that followed the tragedy has ended, and close in the wake of the drama a second tragedy may follow, the end whereof no man can tell. It may snap the silver cord of life in one fond breast if the Eugene Aram of this territory shall be called upon to render his account for deeds committed in the flesh. There seemed to be a general belief in the minds of the people that the verdict in the West case would be a conviction, and curiosity and interest combined to bring out the largest attendance we have yet had. If on former occasions there were come of the representatives of the elite of Delaware present, this last and crowning day brought out many ladies and spinsters of high degree, and many dowagers of blooded ancestry that Dover and its environs boast. At ten o'clock precisely Chief Justice Gilpin, accompanied by Judges Wales, Houston and Wootten, entered from the library in the rear of the court room, their visages wearing an air of extreme gravity, for they of course knew the duty their consciences and oaths called upon them to perform on this occasion. There was a solemn hush in the body of the court as the Chief Justice arose and directed the crier to perform his duty. The jury roll was called, and Attorney General Lore was requested to proceed with his argument on behalf of the State.
THE FINAL ARGUMENT
Mr. Lore than rose and said:--
The law on which we rely in this case has been stated so clearly by my learned colleague that I deem it unnecessary to revert to that to any great degree. I propose to take the theory of counsel for the defense on the burden of proof and reply to it according to our view of the case. They have taken the position that the burden of proving sanity rests upon the State. In 49 New Hampshire Judge Dot explodes this theory in one breath. I feel satisfied that he also disposes of the doctrine of preponderance of testimony in the same decision. When the learned counsel attempted the elucidation of the insanity he was trenching upon the attributes of Divinity itself, he was in an unfathomable sea of supposition and utterly beyond his depth. The proof of insanity at the time of committing the act ought to be as clear and explicit as is the fact of the presence of the party accused. Insanity in the parent does not necessarily suppose insanity in the offspring; it is one degree removed and not necessarily transmitted to the child. It it is proved to the satisfaction of the jury that the prisoner is of unsound mind, the jury may then inquire if it was insanity of that degree that the prisoner was irresistibly impelled to the commission of the crime. In that event the accused is the involuntary agent of the mind under the influence of an overwhelming degree of insanity, and entitle to acquittal. Sanity is one of the strongest presumptions of law, which the defense have been obliged to disprove. There is a question of malice, as in this case. The victim is found horribly mutilated, headless, hands and feet gone; malice is plainly proven, although they would endeavor to disprove it on the ground of insanity. But, gentlemen of the jury, they have failed to prove the insanity of the accused, as I shall show you hereafter.
THE CONFESSION OF WEST
While the State permits the prisoner to speak in his own behalf, even though it accuses himself, yet should the exculpatory part thereof be disproved. The jury many ascertain all the facts by the evidence outside of the confession, and pass upon the facts alone. A man is never vile all at once. Vice is a monster of so frightful mien as to be bated, needs but to be seen. My learned friend (Saulsbury) has dwelt on the fact that no one can pass at a bound from virtue to disgrace. I shall endeavor to show that the life is Isaac C. West, as its forces gathered up to his thirtieth year, was a series of vile conceits and studied crime. The poetry of Cowper was here commented upon by the Attorney General. He referred to Saulsbury's Allusion to Cowper's picture of his mother. He has brought Cowper, that gentle shrinking spirit, here to compare him with the prisoner at the bar. Methinks if he could be brought here to-day and placed by the side of Isaac C. West he would say as he had on another occasion-"I call no man friend who would tread upon the smallest worm." The idea of comparing Cowper with a man who used in his childhood to skin frogs and spit them on a stick. You are told, as one reason that you should not convict Isaac C. West, he is a child of Delaware. God forbid that Delaware should have many such children! I repeat it with a sincere heart, God forbid that Delaware should have many such children:
West looked over his spectacles with bloodshot eyes and glared with all the ferocity of his nature at the prosecuting officer of the State.
He had a delusion they say; he is not crazy because he had a delusion; because he said to Mr. Willimason the negroes of Dover were prosecuting him. The would have you believe he was crazy on the subject of museums, on the subject of the delusion about the negroes and a hundred different things.
WHY EXPERTS WERE NOT PRESENT
You have heard a long and labored argument on the inability of counsel to get experts. Why were they not here? Had they wanted experts they could have gotten them with little trouble. They did not want them. They knew that would hopelessly have damned this case. The explanation of counsel was merely a tub to the whale. In looking at the actors the first on the list is Isaac C. West, Jr. What is his character? The child of good parents, I doubt not, but he has been making a character of himself. Witnesses for the defense swore to his character for peace, good order and quietness. I wish I might give him a better character for the possession of some of the virtues. You will recollect his falling off the load of fodder. In reply to my question as to what he did after this fall, his poor, honest old mother swore that he studied and laid around. Here we found out, inadvertently, that (this man was a crazy man) he even took advantage of that fall to "loaf and lay around;" a man, too, of such strong and muscular development. West was a proud and set up man. Mr. Willimson told you about his gold eye glasses and his clean cut coat-the personification of a fop, a dandy. The strongest element in his character has been his vanity. Note him on his return from college, calling his old colored nurse a fool, and she retorts by thinking him a fool. He was false and idle and proud. Notice him when the hardy son of toil came into the room where there were ladies with his pants rolled up. The young, dainty college student could not stand this, and he made some taunting remark. Up walks the man addressed and asked what West said. But, gentlemen of the jury, he was not only proud, he was a coward; he said nothing, but he wriggled in his chair. Notice, if you please, the element of cruelty in his character. A fitting climax to his surgical operations on helpless frogs and chickens was the grating of the knife on the bones of that poor negro. West's love of wealth has been well authenticated in this trial. Captain Bartle proves that, and the minister proved that, and his own inordinate love of gain led him to the commission of the crime for which he now sits in yonder box awaiting your verdict.
THE TRAGEDY
West tell you the first time he and "Cooch" Turner met was when he, West, was carrying a bucket of water; that "Cooch" offered to carry it for him. We have not condemned the prisoner to sit there and listen to other condemning him. We have given him the benefit of his own statements, and it is by his own utterances that he will be condemned if condemned at all. He would have you believe they met by accident. Wesley Henry (colored) comes here and tells you West was asking for "Cooch" on the morning of the tragedy; he was with the negro in the morning, and in the afternoon, when "Cooch" carried the box upstairs, the meeting was sought by Isaac C. West, and for the purpose of killing "Cooch" Turner. I now come to the act of the tragedy. He took that poor negro, after having made him drunk with brandy, up stairs and then and there coolly butchered him in cold blood. That harmless, inoffensive negro was made the victim of West's most infamous greed of money. When he took that bar of iron and struck at "Cooch" Turner in self defense he meant to kill him. (Bar of iron produce and held alott). Did he man when he grasped that bar of iron in both bands to simply knock the negro down. There, in the providence of God, is the witness that condemns him. The Attorney General read portions of West's confession and commented thereon. Such a scene, said the Attorney General (referring to West's carrying the skin and head out and the dogs running after him), such a brutal, bloodthirsty, bestial scene, I think has never been portrayed in a court of justice. It is not the mind that is at fault in this man, it is the heart; the mind is as healthy as it was the day God gave it him, but it is his cold, calloused heart that is in the fault. When the cry of fire rang out over the quiet of this town on that silent night and the people flocked to the scene of this dread tragedy and saw the headless, handless, footless, skinless body stretched upon the floor, what was the first question that sprung into the minds of those who had gathered there? They asked Why is this? And you, gentlemen of the jury, are here to solve that question. What assault could that reeling, drunken negro offer to the athlete West? Why should you be asked to believe this theory of self-defense? How could West have struck that negro in the bank of the neck when the negro was approaching him with the hammer? It was utterly impossible that such a thing could happen. That blow was given from the bank. It was not an act of self-defense, because Turner was not approaching West when he received his death blow. He tells you the negro said to him, "Boss, you are flush to-night." We prove by witnesses that he states a falsehood. Levy says he had a few shinplasters in his pocket-he was not "flush." He has arranged this all very nicely; he has placed the bar and hammer just where they ought to be, but his plans have failed through the providence of God, which always allow the real motives for the commission of crime.
THE THEORY OF INSANITY
has been offered as a defense. West's eyes have been commented on as evidence of insanity. He did have a peculiar eye. The young man called from Philadelphia notice this peculiarity. Although he conceived an aversion for West he did not hesitate to introduce himself on one occasion when West failed to recognize him. We are told the children were throwing chickens' heads at West in the street. The negroes and children have an aversion to medical students, thinking them very bad people, because they cut up human bodies. Did these children's instincts point toward a human butcher in this instance? You will recollect his look when Williamson read him the recount of the Webster-Parkman murder. His eyes lit up with conscious guilt and not with an insane () of the mind. Incoherency is not a test of insanity. If incoherency were a test of insanity we would be obliged counsel for the prisoner. He passed from West to the heavens above, and soared so high that he approached in his flights of fancy the angelic throng, and dropped so low that he reached even the prisoners at the bar. Isaac C. West's father had a child-a big child, we were told-in 1838, and exactly seven years afterwards Isaac C. West steps out upon the stage of action. Was he the product of that big child? No, gentlemen; there is nothing in this theory of insanity. Trace him through the work of blood in which he was engaged; look at him attending weddings, sitting calm and undisturbed within the sacred precinets of the church; look at him eating his meals regularly and conversing with his acquaintances on the general topics of the day, and at the time having this "dead nigger on his hands." Could human ingenuity have selected a safer retreat than that graveyard? There he might remain safely with the dead; no human foot would intrude into that sanctuary of the dead. Children cross over to the opposite side of the street when coming near a graveyard, and you and I, although we have no belief in the superstitions of children, instinctively
GIVE THE GRAVEYARD A WIDE BERTH.
An insane man could never have taken these things into consideration. The men who saw West moving from day to day come here and tell you they considered him a man of clear and bright intellect. To whom do you entrust administration of your estates? Is it not the man in whose probity you have perfect faith - whom you believe to possess a clear and analytical mind and unsullied character for integrity? The secret of the tragedy I think I have shown you. The cause was not insanity and was not self-defense. West from his confession was insured for $25,000. We are not bound to furnish a motive, yet I conceive we have the motive right here: yes, right here. What was West's financial condition at this time? John H. Bateman, Cashier of the First National Bank of Dover, has told you West drew his last money from the bank in September, 1872. When arrested he had something over twenty-three dollars in his possession. He had made no money by his gas machine, and he had a wife and child to support, and he had an obligation of $600 a year as premiums on his life insurance to pay. His counsel has asked if the State intended to drag in the name of the loved wife. This suggestion came from his own counsel. I honor that woman, and regret from the bottom of my heart that her name should ever have been coupled with that of this brutal man. How would he get the money we are asked. A case has just been decided in Baltimore giving a woman $25,000 for what is said to have been the mutilated body of her husband. The insurance company fought the claim on the ground that the man had never been killed, but the Courts decided adversely and the money has been paid. West's wife would in time have secured the money, and who knows what his influence with that loving wife would have accomplished? I do not say she would have got that money. She would have believed in his innocence as she now does, though all the world turn against him. Just as he thought to grasp the prize it slips away. Never, in my judgment, has such a cold-blooded murder have perpetrated in our little Commonwealth. I have tried to show you that insanity and self-defense were baseless theories, but, on the contrary, there was motive strong and well defined. In conclusion I have to say that had Isaac C. West taken that negro to some lonely spot and killed him it would have been
A CRIME OF FEARFUL MAGNITUDE.
But how much greater is it in fact? Think of the helpless innocence and sleeping age on either side, with nothing but a thin partition between themselves and the fire. I think it, on the whole, the most barbarous crime ever committed in this State. Gentlemen of the jury, you have nothing to do with this man's punishment; the law, speaking through its accepted representatives, will fix that. The ancients represented justice as a beautiful woman, blind and impartial to all outward conditions, seeking simply to ascertain the truth. She never asked if her seekers were white or black, high or low, but asked only for the facts. Think not, if you bring in a verdict of guilty, you add one whit to the poignancy of his sufferings. Let him be where he will, with his innocent wife and child, that headless trunk with be with him always! always! always! Remorse will ever haunt him. He will be a curse to that wife, a constant and a never-dying curse to his relatives. he will be a curse to himself. Better for him that he pass to the spirit world; better for himself and all connected with him. The learned counsel told you he would meet the prisoner at the judgment seat of God; he brought to your view all the actors in this tragedy save one, save "Cooch" Turner. He knew "Cooch" Turner would meet him as an accusing witness in that dread day. The counsel for the accused has told you that there will be no Prosecuting Attorney there. They need none. Isaac C. West's brow will be branded with his crime. Gentlemen, I have done. I leave the case in your hands.
Chief Justice Gilpin announced that the Court would take a recess until three P.M., at which time there was a larger audience gathered than at any former period.
CHARGE OF CHIEF JUSTICE GILPIN
When the Court had reassembled Chief Justice Gilpin arose and in measured tones read the charge to the jury. I will say, par parenthese, the jury were first thanked for the patience they had manifested throughout the weary seven days of the trial. The charge was very able, dealing with questions of law and fact that have come up for adjudication in the course of this remarkable trial. West was at times affected to tears, but at the conclusion of the Judge's reading of the charge leaned his head in his hands and awaited the return of his judges with the verdict, that should consign him to an ignominious grave or restore him to the arms of his kindred. It is related that his sanguine wife on Saturday night last, believing he would be acquitted, got everything in readiness at her father's home for his reception.
After defining the different grades of homicide and commenting at some length on the questions of law, the Judge passed on to a discussion of the two pleas set up in this case. Murder, he said, results from preconceived malignity of heart, from a wicked, depraved and malignant spirit; a heart regardless of social duty and perversely bent upon mischief. I now proceed to consider the nature and character of the defense which the prisoner at the bar relied on for obtaining an acquittal at your hands - the defense of insanity. Where a prisoner is totally and permanently insane all his acts, however atrocious, are excused; he cannot properly be said to have any intention, and therefore is held to be utterly incapable of committing crime. Such a mental condition or state of the mind is called general insanity -that is, insane on all subjects-and a person may be totally and temporarily insane-that is altogether insane on all subjects for a time and to such a high degree that for the time being the reason, the conscience, the will and judgement are utterly overborne and overwhelmed, so that an act done during the continuance of the malady cannot be said to be a voluntary act. Or a person may be partially insane. When this is the condition of the mind it is called monomaniac or insane delusion. Now, whether such partial insanity can be held sufficient to exempt a person from responsibility for criminal acts will depend upon the special circumstances of each particular case, the nature and character of the delusion, the force or degree of its intensity or its controlling power, and especially whether the act done and which is charged as a crime was committed under the direct and irresistible influence of such insane delusion are always matters of vital importance in determining the question of responsibility. It is not every foolish or frantic humor of a person, or moody sadness or depression of spirits, or strange and unaccountable language or conduct, that will show him to be laboring under insanity or out of his right mind. The law, which is founded upon reason and common sense, requires something more and beyond this. Nor is partial insanity or insane delusion always or necessarily an excuse for crime. On the contrary, I expressly charge you that it can only be so considered where it utterly deprives the party of his reason, so that he is for the time being rendered incapable of determining between right and wrong in respect to the act charged as criminal. The question is not whether he was insane on an subject whatever, but rather whether he was insane at the time and in respect to the nature of the acts committed and charged against him as constituting his offence. If it were otherwise there would be an absolute immunity from punishment for crime committed under any species of insane delusion. If he is capable at the time of distinguishing between the right and the wrong of that particular act, if he understands and knows that act is wrong, he is held according to every sound principle of morals and law to be responsible for his conduct in that regard. The first great cardinal rule is this:-Every person is presumed to be same and to possess a sufficient degree of reason to be responsible for his crimes until the contrary shall be proved to the entire satisfaction of the jury; that is to say, until it be proved beyond a reasonable doubt that at the time he committed the criminal act charged he was an insane man. This rule is primary, cardinal, fundamental and of universal application in England and most of the States of this country. It is the settled law of this State.
THE PRISONER AT THE BAR,
therefore, is to be considered by you to be a sane man, and capable of committing crime until the contrary be clearly established by the evidence beyond a reasonable doubt. You will therefore bear this rule in mind in all your deliberations, for it is the ground upon which you must stand in prosecuting your investigation upon this subject.
Now, as to the plea of self-defense, which the prisoner relies on as one of the grounds upon which he claims an acquittal. It is proper to remark the deceased, Henry Turner, was invited by the prisoner into his room in the Kerbin House. He was no housebreaker in the night time; not a trespasser, but was there rightfully and by invitation. Homicide is self-defense-that is, where one is assaulted upon a sudden affray, and in the defense of his person, where certain and immediate suffering may be the consequence of waiting for assistance of the law, and there is no probably means of escape, he kills his assailant. To reduce homicide in self-defense to this degree it must be shown by sufficient proof that the slayer was closely pressed by his assailant, and retreated as far as he conveniently could in good faith, with the honest intent to avoid the violence of the assault, and the jury must be satisfied that unless he had killed the assailant he was in imminent danger either of losing his own life or suffering enormous bodily harm. It is the duty of the Court to explain the Law to the jury; this duty I have endeavored to discharge. The most important part of your duty still remains to be performed, and I pray to God most sincerely that He will impress your hearts with a due sense of the solemn responsibilities now resting upon you.
The jury were conducted to the room set apart for their deliberations and the majority of the audience dispersed in the vicinity of the Court House to await the verdict.

to add your section.

Newspaper Location

Leaflet © OpenStreetMap contributors

An account of the trial of Isaac C. West Jr. in Dover, Delaware, detailing the defense's insanity plea, the prosecution's closing arguments, and the final charge given by Chief Justice Gilpin to the jury regarding the case.

Citations

Genealogy (Evidence Explained)

New York Daily Herald, June 11, 1873, p. 10, 'West's Trial'; digital images, Newspapers.com (https://www.newspapers.com/article/new-york-daily-herald-issac-west-trial/203573279/ : accessed August 10, 2026), clip page for Issac West Trial by user englishwalter.

APA 7th

New York Daily Herald. (1873, June 11). West's Trial: The closing argument by Attorney General; The judge's charge. p. 10. https://www.newspapers.com/article/new-york-daily-herald-issac-west-trial/203573279/

MLA 9th

“West's Trial: The Closing Argument by Attorney General; The Judge's Charge.” New York Daily Herald, 11 June 1873, p. 10. Newspapers.com, https://www.newspapers.com/article/new-york-daily-herald-issac-west-trial/203573279/.

Chicago

"West's Trial: The Closing Argument by Attorney General; The Judge's Charge." New York Daily Herald, June 11, 1873. https://www.newspapers.com/article/new-york-daily-herald-issac-west-trial/203573279/.

Isaac C. West Jr.WilliamsonGilpinHoustonWoottenLore

Tags

Legal Notice
Contributed by Walter English