The Gazette
The Professor's Murder: Startling Incidents of the Singular Crime in Dover

Transcription
THE PROFESSOR'S MURDER
Startling Incidents of the Singular Crime in Dover.
DOVER, Del, Dec. [[9?]]—This community was startled on Thursday morning, by the announcement that the body of a man, partially burned, headless and footless, had been found in the office of Dr. Isaac C. West. An examination of the premises and a view of the remains coupled with the absence of Dr. West and a negro named Cooch Turner, led to the belief that an atrocious murder had been committed, followed by an attempt to burn a row of houses to conceal the crime. The facts so far as can be ascertained are as follows:—
A young man aged about 24 years, going under the name of Dr. Isaac C. West, occupied a room in the second story of a new building, recently erected by James M. Kerbin, on Lockerman street. He professed to treat pulmonary diseases by the inhaling process, and had in his room an apparatus for the manufacture of a gas which he called electro-oxygen. On Wednesday night, about hald past 11 o'clock, West left the Capital Hotel, where he has boarded, sauing that he was going to his office to attend to some gas which he was preparing, conveying the impression that he had left the lamp burning under the [[retort?]]
THE PROFESSOR'S LABORATORY ON FIRE.
At about half past 12 o'clock Mr G W Benn, who lives adjoining West's office, was awakened by his wife, who told him she believed something serious had happened next door, as she heard a noise as though something heavy had fallen, followed by a sound like that made by a sewing machine. Mr Benn got out on the window cooping, and looking into West's window saw that the place was on fire. He gave the alarm, and with some neighbors broke into the room and soon had the fire under control, but a spectacle that filled all present with horror was presented when a light was brought into the room. On the floor lay the headless and footless body of a man partially roasted by the fire. The first impression was that this was the body of Dr West, and that he had been killed by an explosion of the gas which he had been manufacturing. This impression, however, was not sustained by the condition of the body or its surroundings,
THE MUTILATED BODY.
The body, when found, was lying on its back, with a parcel of burnt pine wood, apparently pieces of boxes, under and about it. A dry goods box, which was in a light blaze when the men entered the room to put out the fire, was at one side of the body. The left arm was thrown up as though over the head, and the right was extended outward and downward. The bowels were exposed. The ribs were detached from the breast bone as though with a saw or cleaver. The flesh on the breast and back was roasted, but not charred. The whole body presented the appearance of having been skinned. Not a particle of the cuticle was to be seen. The head was entirely gone, and not a trace of it was to be found in the room. The neck looked as though the head had been severed from it with an axe. Both feet were taken off above the ankle joints, and no traces of them were in the room. There was not a particle of clothing about the body.
A MURDER, NOT AN EXPLOSION.
The brim of a silk hat and pieces of a coat and waistcoat belonging to West were found in the room away from the body. Some pieces of a plaid shirt, like one worn by Cooch Turner, before his disappearance, and a piece of striped pantaloon stuff, were found in his room. It is conjectured that the mutilated body had been placed on one end of the dry goods box, from which it fell after the fire had burnt that side of the box away. This seems probably from the fact that the back, which was next the floor when the body was found, with a few pieces of burnt wood about it, was burned more than the front, and also that the floor immediately under the body was not burned. The condition of the room did not encourage the belief in an explosion. The tank supposed to have contained the patent gas was empty, but it gave no evidence of an explosion. Three glass jars used for purifying the gas in its passage from the retort to the tank, and the glass in the windows were uninjured. The plaster was not broken. The fire had done but little damage.
THE INQUEST.
On Thursday morning an inquest was held and the jury were unable to decide on a verdict. Many theories were discussed as to the true solution of the mystery. West was not to be found. At 6 o'clock on Friday evening Dr West arrived at Dover by the train and delivered himself up to the Sheriff. He was taken to the jail, all the inhabitants turning out when they heard of his arrival. He was visited by his father-in-law and friends, and ate a heart supper in their presence. The jury was again convened and the prisoner taken before them. He then made the following confession:
On Monday, December 2, I was taking a bucket of water in my room in the morning. Henry Turner, the deceased, came along, and said, "Boss, I will carry that up for you." I told him I would carry it up, as I had some work for him to do, if he would do it. Turner asked what the work was. I told him I had a large box at Capt. Battell's. Turner said he would do it some time in the afternoon. I met him on the street about three o'clock. He said he was ready to carry the box for me. He got a wheelbarrow from Mr Collison and took the box up to my room for me. My room is in Kirbin's building. I took out my pocketbook and paid him twenty-five cents. He said, "Boss, you seem to be pretty flush." He said, "Won't you give me a drink, or something to get a drink?" I said I would if he would go down to the bar next door. He said then after he got his supper he would come back and get water to fill my gasometer—that he would not charge me anything for that, as I was so good to him. We went down together, and I paid for Turner's drink at Levy's bar. The sun was then about half an hour high. We came out together, and then separated. As we came out of the door, he said, "Boss, I will be on hand in about half an hour, or by sunset." I had just got to my room and unlocked the door when Turner came up. I went on up stairs ahead of him and unlocked the room door up stairs and went in ahead of him. I had taken my gasometer to pieces that day, intending to fasten a small sledge hammer I had taken there to the weights. The sledge hammer was sitting just inside the door. The other weights were over in the corner about eight feet further on. One of the weights was a bolt or piece of an axle. It was about two feet long and an inch and a quarter in diameter. I had just got about where this bolt was sitting when I turned and saw Turner with the hammer in his hand. As soon as he noticed that I saw him he said, "Give me your pocket-book or I will kill you."
I [[snatched?]] up the bolt or piece of axle, and just as I did he struck me with the hammer. He struck me on top of my hat, denting the hat in, but did not touch my head, as I was stooping over. I then struck him with the bolt of piece of axle, intending to strike him on the head, but missed his head and struck him on the neck, I think below the left ear. He fell, and I don't think he ever breathed after that. This was just about sunset He fell over on his side. I then felt of his pulse and found that he was dead. I did not intend to kill him, but only intended to knock him down, so that he would not kill me. I left the body laying there, and came up to [[Wm?]] Fountain's hotel and got my supper. I did not go back any more that evening. I went back again on Tuesday morning about 10 or 11 o'clock. I then thought I would cut him up in pieces and carry him off and bury him.
CUTTING UP THE BODY.
I cut off his head and feet with a penknife and skinned the body. I had broken several of the bones with the bolt or pieces of axle previously ; this was all done before dinner. I went to my dinner that day, but do not know the exact time. I was not there in the afternoon to the best of my knowledge. In the afternoon I got a horse and carriage of Mr. Fountain, and went out home to Hazletville, thinking it would be dark in the evening when I came back to take the remains away and bury them. I think it was about 6 o'clock in the evening of Tuesday when I returned. I brought down the skin of Turner in the water bucket; had a piece of paper over the top of the bucket, which was about even full. The horse smelt it and would not let me take it I set it down just inside of the outside door, and locked the door. I then brought the horse and carriage up to the stable. I went up to the hotel and prepared myself, then thought I would carry off the remains in a bucket and bury them. I got my supper at Hazletville. I think it was about 8 o'clock. I went back to my room.
I then took the bucket that had the skin in it and started out on the street with it. I had not got far before there were two dogs after me. I was going down Lockman to New street, and then turned into Now street I found the ground was frozen, and I had nothing to dig a hole with. I then turned and brought it back to my room again. I then remained up in my room thinking what to do. I then concluded to tear a large box to pieces I had and make a box that would hold the remains, and ship them on the Delaware Railroad to some point undeterminated, and then bury them. I found that it was getting late, and I could not stay any later that night. I then came up to the hotel, and went to bed about 11 o'clock on Tuesday evening. On Wednesday my foot was burning me, and I did not go back to my room until about 9 o'clock, and found the remains smelling so that I could not ship them on the Delaware railroad. I was about at different places in town that day until the afternoon. Got my dinner at Fountain's Hotel as usual. I think I went back to my room about 2 o'clock Wednesday afternoon.
MUTILATING THE HEAD.
I took my knife and cut some pieces off the abdomen. I cut the lips and nose off the head. I then took the bolt of piece of axle and struck the head. I am under the impression I struck the head before I cut the lips and nose, intending to mash the head up so that it sould [[could]] not be recognized. It was my intention to skin the head; then thought if skinned the head would still retain its shape and be recognized. I then took the head in a bucket and took it down to a lime heap near the railroad, and put lime over it, and put it back in the bucket, and then carried it back to the place where I buried it with a spade I got from the side of Mrs Jones's outhouse, under a heap of dead briars, near the corner of Water street and railroad. I then cam back to my room about ten o'clock at night. I had a candle and two lamps. One for the purpose of burning alcohol and the other for kerosene oil. I took the bucket and put the skin in it to carry it away. I went out on the street with it and saw some one coming. I took it back to my room again.
EXPERIMENTING ON THE FEET AND SKIN.
I melted some tallow on the floor and stuck the candle in it, and then took one of the feet and pouring some alcohol over it, set fire to it. I thought that would change the color of it, and spilt some on the floor, and that also caught fire. I had the night before that time piled the box over the body, and put the pieces of the box on top of the box. I intended if the alcohol changed the color of the skin on the feet I was then going to spread the skin out on the floor, and put alcohol on it to change the color of it by burning the alcohol. I found the burning of alcohol did not change the color of the skin. I intended if it did to put the skin back on the body and fit it as well as I could. The alcohol on the floor caught fire. I tried to put out the fire with my hat, but could not. Then I gathered up the feet and hands and skin in my hands, and got out of the room as soon as I could, fearing the fire might catch to the powder in the hole, and walked toward the Methodist grave yard with the feet, hands and skin. After I got off some distance from the house I saw that the fire had gone out. Did not see more than one light burning. I started to go back to the room again, but I was afraid to go back, knowing that the candle was setting on the floor. I had got up near Mrs Jones's new house, and I saw the fire flash up again.
IN THE METHODIST GRAVEYARD.
I then turned and went back toward the graveyard, where I left the hands, feet, and skin. I then took them up and carried them over into the Methodist graveyard, and waited there until the fire was put out. I then went and buried the skin along the side of the railroad. I started up to get the hands and feet to bury them. I heard the whistle of the four o'clock down train. I raked some lime over them between two lime piles ; I then went up to the depot, and waited there until the train came, and got on board the train with a bundle of clothes ; got on the train next to the town side, and went to Delmar; there got off and walked to Salisbury, Maryland, down the track to the railroad. I went up the Tracy's Hotel, in Salisbury, Maryland, and remained there until this morning, Friday, the [[6th?]], and then got on the train coming north. Came up to Farmington and got off the train there. I then walked up to Harrington, got on evening train and came to Dover and delivered myself up to the Sheriff. I had previously called for a constable at Harrington to deliver myself up to.
WEST SAYS HE IS CRAZY.
On Saturday a friend visited West and was with him all day. This friend told several persons at the hotel where he was staying that West had been insane since a boy. Since his friend's visit West has told another story.
He says that he inhaled some of the gas to see whether it was of sufficient strength, and that it drove him frantic. Turner happened to come into the room at the time, and he killed him.
TWO HAPPY MEN.
A short time before the murder of the poor negro, Ike West met a Mr. Kellum of this town. After some conversation West said, looking at Kellum from top to toe, "Kellum, you and I are just about the same size and build."
During the conversation West referred two or three times to this fact, and on parting with Kellum, said:
"You have never tried my new gas. Come up to my room and I will administer some to you."
Mr. Kellum declined. He says now that he is very glad he did. About the same time West had a conversation with Mr. Watson, a lawyer of this place. West suddenly burst out withL
"Watson, you and I are of pretty near the same weight and build."
Watson said, "I will bet cigars I am the heavier man."
They weighed, and West's weight was 196 pounds and Watson's 194. West than began to speak of his new gas, and pressed Mr. Watson to go up to his room and inhale some to see how agreeable it was. Mr. Watson excused himself. He is a happy man to—day.
About the same time West met a Mr. Windolph, and after some talk said:
"Windolph, you are much the same made man as I am; you are about as broad across the chest [pushing aside Mr. Windolph's coat and feeling his chest]. We might easily be taken for one another on a dark night."
West than asked Mr. Windolph to go to his laboratory and inhale the new gas which he had invented. Mr. Windolph put him off with some excuse. Subsequently West pressed Mr. Windolph to visit his room and try the gas, but Mr. Windolph refused. Mr. Windolph congratulates himself on being in possession of all his limbs and his skin, and on being able to attend to business.
to add your section.
Newspaper Location








An article detailing the gruesome murder and dismemberment of an Henry Turner by Dr. Isaac C. West in Dover, including West's confession regarding the killing of a man named Turner.
Citations
The Gazette, "The Professor's Murder: Startling Incidents of the Singular Crime in Dover," 14 December 1872, page 2, column 1; digital image, Newspapers.com (https://www.newspapers.com/article/the-gazette/203849838/ : accessed 14 August 2026), clip page by user englishwalter.
The Professor's Murder: Startling Incidents of the Singular Crime in Dover. (1872, December 14). The Gazette, p. 2. https://www.newspapers.com/article/the-gazette/203849838/
"The Professor's Murder: Startling Incidents of the Singular Crime in Dover." The Gazette, 14 Dec. 1872, p. 2. Newspapers.com, https://www.newspapers.com/article/the-gazette/203849838/.
The Gazette. "The Professor's Murder: Startling Incidents of the Singular Crime in Dover." December 14, 1872. https://www.newspapers.com/article/the-gazette/203849838/.