Detroit Free Press
Roots of Collecting: Black antiques reveal a painful past

Transcription
ROOTS OF COLLECTING - Black antiques often reveal a painful view of America's racist past
by Ralph Finch
More and more people - blacks, whites, history buffs and antiques collectors in general - are becoming interested in the paraphernalia of America's early race relations, but most must come to terms with items they wish had never existed.
The vast majority of 1800-1950 ethnic artifacts depicting blacks - toys, dolls, "novelties" - is so demeaning that, for years, many were destroyed while others were kept under wraps for fear of offending not only blacks, but most whites as well.
Yet with the recent increased interest in black American history, early black collectibles are being seen in a new light - beyond their questionable esthetic value.
"When I started selling black memorabilia, 80 percent of my customers were white." says Malinda Saunders, a Washington, D.C. antiques dealer.
"Now it has almost reversed, and 70 percent of my customers are black. They realize it is part of their heritage, part of their culture. Blacks are beginning to understand the negative as well as the positive about this material."
The value of these items is increasing rapidly - black items generally are worth more than similar items depicting whites - as the interest in them rises.
The growth is attributed to the soaring interest in American antiques in general, but also as a minuscule milestone of how far our nation has come from the rampant bitterness and ugliness of our past.
This material can be "very offensive," says Titus Brown, who is black, especially to "the majority of the American public which doesn't realize stuff like this existed. Most people prefer not having to face this aspect of our past." Brown is a research associate at the Black Archives Research Center and Museum in Tallahassee, on the Florida A&M University campus.
Museum exhibits show the history of black Americans from slavery to the present. Included are exhibits of African artifacts as well as early American dolls, post-cards, slave documents, trade cards and sheet music.
And then there is the "Coon Room."
ANTIQUES - Black collectibles reveal a painful past
from page 3D
"'Coon' is a commonly used 19th- and 20th-century racist word used by whites to refer to blacks," notes Brown. "Most of the stuff in the Coon Room is racist, so we thought it was an appropriate name."
This material is separated because, he says, "we don't want primary school kids exposed to stuff which - at their age - they can't conceptualize in terms of the total historical situation."
Here are housed particularly painful, intensely demeaning examples of America's racial past - "Ku Klux Klan memorabilia; illustrations depicting blacks as subhuman; signs showing babies as alligator bait; lots of material using the term 'coon,' 'nigger,' 'darkie' - things that excessively distort the historical characteristics and situations of blacks," Brown explains.
All this material is collectible today. But it wasn't always so.
"At one point, in the mid-1960s, black people were buying this stuff to destroy it," says Malinda Saunders. "That was before they became aware of the importance of it."
Even children's dolls can have an ugly side.
Last year the Wenham (Mass.) Museum exhibited about 100 antique black dolls. But it didn't display dolls that have racially exaggerated features.
"This year (though April 7) we are showing 277 black dolls," says Marilyn Corning, museum administrative assistant, "and some of them are very stereotypical. We are holding our breath, but so far the response has been positive. These dolls, which date from 1840-1990, are part of doll-making history."
POPULAR COLLECTIBLES
Ethnically-correct dolls are also perhaps the hottest segment of doll collecting.
"Antique black dolls have had a strong resurgence in the past five years," says George Theriault. "All the doll people - those who collect French, German, bisque, cloth or whatever - are seeking black dolls today."
Theriault is the co-owner of Theriault's in Annapolis, Md., the only auction house dealing solely in collectible dolls. Last year it did a $6-million business.
"Antique black dolls were never terribly popular (in their time) and, hence are very scarce," Theriault explains. "The really rare ones are those originally designed as black people, as opposed to white dolls painted black. In the contemporary doll field, even black 'Francie' is worth more than the white Barbie of the same year."
One prime example is the 15-inch-high doll shown on today's Homestyle section cover. Attributed to French doll maker Casimir Bru, the doll has its original costume and silver and gold jewelry. It was auctioned last year by Theriault for $20,000. (The record for an antique black doll is around $84,000.)
CONTEMPTUOUS PAPER
While black dolls, whatever their design, were created to be loved, items on paper usually were created to illustrate a contempt for blacks.
"Ninety-eight percent of it is offensive," acknowledges Kit Barry of Brattleboro, Vt. He's referring to early advertising showing blacks.
"We in the (collecting) field understand that, but the public's first reaction when introduced to it is to be offended; they aren't aware of its social-history context.
Barry is a major dealer of pre-1900 ephemera (material produced for a short-time usage). "Usually it's printed material on paper," he explains.
Most ephemera takes the form of advertising, and "a culture reveals itself through its advertising," says Barry, who is white. "It shows its humor, values, prejudices - every aspect of its culture.
"Most all black images were caricature, leaning from mild fun-poking to out-and-out cruelty. In ephemera, if you take the various ethnic groups portrayed, the black category outstrips all other categories by a huge margin.
"If you work from the highest number of
ANTIQUES - Black collectibles reveal a painful past
From page 14D
pieces, from one to 10 with blacks being 10, you would drop to five for the next group - Chinese. After that you'd get Irish, German, and Jewish, in descending order.
"I can't back this up academically, but if you figure that most ephemera is by definition advertising for the masses and therefore is demographic art, one would have to ask: How much did advertising graphics influence, perpetuate and galvanize - in some cases even create - public perception of ethnic minorities."
CREATING PERCEPTIONS
Titus Brown says the effect was extensive.
Speaking by phone from Tallahassee, he says: "Before the current period of black pride, many blacks' self-images were influenced by these representations. It taught us to think ill of ourselves, to think that we were subhuman, childlike and incapable of taking care of ourselves."
He tells of a collection of early Florida post-cards "showing blacks in negative situations. If you were in Florida and mailed cards to rural northern areas, where there were few - if any - blacks, the (recipients') perception of Southern blacks would be distorted."
But the perception as well as the reception of black-related collectibles today is growing sharper.
Gwen Goldman of Adamstown, Pa., has been an antiques dealer for 25 years and an ephemera dealer for 20, and she says she has seen considerable interest in the hobby since attending the first Black Memorabilia/Collectible Showcase show in 1984 in Silver Springs, Md.
These shows feature around 50 dealers, she says, and while the majority of her customers prefer material representing blacks in a complimentary light - "Women like to buy positive family scenes" - she still has strong sales in the derogatory material.
"Blacks who are writers, teachers or historians will buy the offensive type as educational material," she says.
Malinda Saunders has been selling black-related collectibles for about 12 years, and, since 1984, has sponsored the Silver Springs show.
"We always have people - blacks and whites - who come to our shows for the first time and are offended by some of this material," Saunders, who is black, admits.
"A lot of the young ones - again, black as well as white - aren't aware of the signs that used to be on the water fountains and rest rooms, signs such as 'Colored Served in the Rear,' 'No Blacks Allowed,' etc."
Saunders adds that more people are becoming interested in the positive examples of our past.
The positive? "Much of the artwork, the family pictures, beautiful bisque pieces, beautiful dolls, historical items from the Reconstruction period - and information about the positive contributions blacks have made."
BLACK ANTIQUES DON'T END WITH DOLLS, PAPER
There's a wide array of black-related collectible material in addition to dolls and paper items. Most of it was created by whites, and nearly all displays a racist attitude.
Among the categories:
- Minstrel-inspired clockwork windup toys.
Most carry derogatory names such as the 1880s "Brudder Bones," "Fiddler" and "Poor Old Joe Banjo Player," priced at $2,000 each in fine condition. "Hey Hey the Chicken Snatcher," a 1920s Marx windup, is priced around $400.
- Toy banks.
"Initiation - First Degree" is an 1890s mechnical bank with a goat the butts a black who deposits a coin in a frog's mouth ($2,000). "Darktown Battery," circa 1888, combines a black pitcher, catcher and batsman ($500, with a rarer white version priced at $700).
- Games.
Milton Bradley's circa-1916 "The Jolly Darkie Target Game" (rough value, $175) has players attempt to throw balls into a black man's gaping mouth. A similar item, made in England in 1928, is "The Picaninny Bowling Game," valued around $225. "The Coon Hunt Game," a circa-1920 offering by Parker Brothers, shows four exaggeratedly drawn black me searching for a raccoon hiding in a tree; it's valued around $225. Another "Parker pleaser" is a 1920s "Old Bark Door Target," complete with a "harmless air rifle." The purpose of the game was to hit the face of a black person looking out the barn window.
- Sheet music, family photos, Civil War-related items, postcards, political memorabilia, folk art, literary collectibles, figural images, and containers (for cookies, salt and pepper, tobacco, syrup). "Amos 'n' Andy" items, following the 1928 introduction of the characters on radio, also form a popular category.
- Novelties.
This is perhaps the largest single category, with a heavy emphasis on trinkets for tourists. Writes P.J. Gibbs in her out-of-print book, Black Collectibles Sold in America: "Every conceivable novelty company, toy company, southern and northern state tourist bureau, doll company and other retailers created novelties with blacks as the main subject."
RALPH FINCH
to add your section.
Newspaper Location








An exploration of the collecting of historical Black Americana and racially derogatory ephemera, examining the tension between preserving artifacts of a racist past and the painful imagery they contain.
Citations
Ralph Finch, "Roots of Collecting: Black antiques reveal a painful past," Detroit Free Press, 23 March 1991, p. 45; digital image, Newspapers.com (https://www.newspapers.com/article/detroit-free-press-roots-of-collecting-p/203898932/ : accessed 15 August 2026).
Finch, R. (1991, March 23). Roots of collecting: Black antiques reveal a painful past. Detroit Free Press, 45. https://www.newspapers.com/article/detroit-free-press-roots-of-collecting-p/203898932/
Finch, Ralph. "Roots of Collecting: Black antiques reveal a painful past." Detroit Free Press, 23 Mar. 1991, p. 45. Newspapers.com, https://www.newspapers.com/article/detroit-free-press-roots-of-collecting-p/203898932/.
Finch, Ralph. "Roots of Collecting: Black antiques reveal a painful past." Detroit Free Press, March 23, 1991. https://www.newspapers.com/article/detroit-free-press-roots-of-collecting-p/203898932/.