The Louisville Defender
Girl Says Police Beat Her

Transcription
Girl Says Police Beat Her
Blackjack Wallop
Breaks Nose; Kicked
A young woman accused a policeman of brutally beating her in the police holdover. She said officer James Ellis broke her nose with his blackjack, kicked her and put his knees in her stomach.
The victim, Cecilia Ann West, 18, 1020 W. Madison and another woman, Mary Agnes Stephenson, 526 West Street, were arrested by two policewomen on vagrancy charges Dec. 11.
They had been turned over to Ellis for booking when the alleged beating occurred. Twice before Ellis was accused of shootings.
Attorneys for Miss West, C. E. Frank Tucker and C. J. Lunderman, said they would seek a warrant for Ellis' arrest for assault and battery.
Police Court Judge Peter Muir refused to issue the warrant, saying it wasn't his policy to issue warrants for policemen. The lawyers said they would ask some other magistrate to issue the warrant.
Under questioning by Lunderman in Police Court, Ellis admitted hitting the woman. He said Miss West got rough and he was scared.
Ellis filed assault and battery charges against Miss West after he alleged that she bit and kicked him and tore his shirt.
In police court Dec. 21st officer Ellis said Miss West insisted upon using the telephone and that he told her she could not until she had been seated. When she went to the booth anyway Ellis said that he slammed the receiver down and ordered her to be seated. When she insisted on standing rather than sitting he said he pushed her down.
“She stood up again and he pushed her down again. A scuffle ensued and I took the handle end of my slapjack and hit her across the legs. When she got up a third time I hit her with the flat part of my open hand, Ellis stated. From this lick her nose was allegedly broken.
The officer said that he wasn't sure whether he hit her that hard or whether she fell against the cell."
The officer told the court that he was attempting to keep the holdover orderly and that it was his rule that all prisoners must be seated while they are being stated.
Miss West told the Defender that she was ordered to be seated by the officer but she doesn't hear so well and did not understand him. She said he beat her with his fist and kicked her. A policeman took him off her once but he came back and resumed mistreatment of her.
He said that proper action would be taken after a statement is taken from another prisoner who saw all of the action.
Miss West was held to the grand jury on the A&B charge.
Officer Ellis has been a member of the police force for two years. He was cited for capturing singlehandedly five ex-convicts from Texas.
He also seriously wounded an eleven-year-old boy when a shot from his gun ricocheted. He was shooting at a fleeing 15-year-old boy he was attempting to arrest. Later he killed a man who fled from him after it was alleged he had been in a knife fight.
Miss West told the Defender that the officer remarked while he was beating her that, “He hated dirty black bi--hes.”
Newspaper Location









A news article reporting on a young woman, Cecilia Ann West, who accused a police officer of physical assault while in custody
Citations
The Louisville Defender, 30 December 1954, p. 1, 'Girl Says Police Beat Her'; digital image, Newspapers.com (https://www.newspapers.com/article/the-louisville-defender-girl-says-police/205144339/ : accessed 2 September 2026).
Girl Says Police Beat Her. (1954, December 30). The Louisville Defender, 1. https://www.newspapers.com/article/the-louisville-defender-girl-says-police/205144339/
"Girl Says Police Beat Her." The Louisville Defender, 30 Dec. 1954, p. 1. Newspapers.com, https://www.newspapers.com/article/the-louisville-defender-girl-says-police/205144339/.
"Girl Says Police Beat Her." The Louisville Defender, December 30, 1954. https://www.newspapers.com/article/the-louisville-defender-girl-says-police/205144339/.