Lexington Herald-Leader
Horowitz: Today's blacks deserve fruits of ancestors' labor

Transcription
open mike
A forum for readers under 30
Horowitz:
Today's blacks deserve fruits of ancestors' labor
by Doron Jamil Townsell
A couple of weeks ago, college newspapers around the country were asked to publish an ad by conservative writer David Horowitz stating why blacks do not deserve reparations for slavery. It was very upsetting to a lot of black Americans.
It's amazing that in the 21st century people like Horowitz still cannot see the complete picture and understand why African-Americans deserve, among many other things, reparations. I say "deserve" and not "need." Black people in America have persevered through the worst of conditions without reparations; we do have a right to them because we suffered such great injustice.
The Advertisement That College Newspapers SHOULD Have Run:
3 Reasons Why David Horowitz is Bad for Blacks-And Racist Too
One He thinks slavery was good for Blacks Two He thinks because some Blacks receive welfare, no Blacks deserve reparations Three He thinks Blacks make good servants for his shameless self-promotion.
Steve Benson Arizona Republic
According to Horowitz, only the children of slaves long gone had the right to receive reparations. The simple example of a relay race shows why that is not true. The runner who began the race does not finish it; after running a prescribed distance, each runner must pass a baton to a teammate so he or she may advance. Thus, each person on the team plays a vital role in the race.
So just because I'm in (I hope) the last leg of the race against oppression and injustice does not mean I'm not a part of or affected by what happened at the beginning of the contest 150 years ago.
Of course, everybody who is alive today had nothing to do with slavery, but the effects of the horrendous system continue to play out in the new millennium.
Now let's add some elements to our relay race. Let's say that there are three teams competing against one another and that the winner will receive a large cash prize. Also note that Team 3's work raises the bulk of the prize money.
Team 1 starts the race with no problems and encounters no obstacles, which allows its runners to take a break and rest during the race. Eventually they go on and win first prize.
Team 2, however, has to jump over a few hurdles, which ultimately slows down the runners. They are able to continue toward the finish line, however, and win second place and a small amount of cash.
Unfortunately, Team 3 not only has to jump the hurdles but also has run the first part of the race with a heavy ball and chain attached to each team member's legs. The balls and chains are removed in the final stretch but replaced with a lighter and smaller version to wear around their necks, choking the runner's cognitive abilities.
There is no third prize. When Team 3 objects, Team 1's fans, who make up the majority of the audience, say Team 3 deserves no prize money even though the race was unfairly run.
Is that logical, fair, just, moral or right?
The principle connection between a team's runners is the baton because it must be passed from one to the other for them to complete the relay. The baton represents everything that is passed down from generation to generation.
Be it slave mentality or the will to succeed, be it positive or negative, the baton contains every aspect of our sojourn here in America.
So yes, blacks do very much deserve reparations for slavery even though it took place 150 years ago. Our past directly affects our present and future.
Let's not downplay the past in hopes of freeing ourselves of guilt. Instead, let's acknowledge the past, learn from it and plot a new course for the future that benefits all people.
Doron Jamil Townsell is a senior at the University of Kentucky, where he is majoring in secondary education.
to add your section.
Newspaper Location












In this opinion piece, Doron Jamil Townsell argues that African-Americans deserve reparations for slavery, using a relay race metaphor to illustrate how past systemic injustice affects the present.
Citations
Lexington Herald-Leader, "Horowitz: Today's blacks deserve fruits of ancestors' labor," 8 April 2001, p. 70, col. 1; digital image, Newspapers.com (https://www.newspapers.com/article/lexington-herald-leader-horowitz-doron/202633723/ : accessed 19 November 2026).
Townsell, D. J. (2001, April 8). Horowitz: Today's blacks deserve fruits of ancestors' labor. Lexington Herald-Leader, 70. https://www.newspapers.com/article/lexington-herald-leader-horowitz-doron/202633723/
Townsell, Doron Jamil. "Horowitz: Today's blacks deserve fruits of ancestors' labor." Lexington Herald-Leader, 8 Apr. 2001, p. 70. Newspapers.com, https://www.newspapers.com/article/lexington-herald-leader-horowitz-doron/202633723/.
Townsell, Doron Jamil. "Horowitz: Today's blacks deserve fruits of ancestors' labor." Lexington Herald-Leader, April 8, 2001, 70. https://www.newspapers.com/article/lexington-herald-leader-horowitz-doron/202633723/.