Clarion-Ledger

Mississippi Notebook: Letters regarding the Emmett Till kidnapping and slaying

9/18/1955Jackson, MississippiAwaiting review Civil Rights (1950-1980)
Image
100%
Mississippi Notebook: Letters regarding the Emmett Till kidnapping and slaying 1

Transcription

Awaiting Review1 contributor
keira davies Read only

Mississippi Notebook
By Tom Ethridge

NOTE: We are indebted to many readers for their letters and comments prompted by our recent discussions here on the sensational Emmett Till kidnap-slaying.
In the following letters we have withheld names when requested to do so. Otherwise, we assume readers do not object to use of actual names as signed to their letters.

"STATE ON TRIAL"
Many more than just two of us are on trial ... our whole state will be judged at America's bar of justice ... there can and must be only one verdict for Emmett Till's killers. Just sign this--
"A CHRISTIAN"
West Point, Miss.

"ALL HAD PARTS"
... Those who taught that boy to whistle the Wolf Call and make him think it was smart; those who failed to teach him respect for womanhood; the mother who failed to keep what they say was an afflicted child near her; the Uncle who knew the seriousness of the situation but failed to get the boy out of the way immediately--all had their parts in this tragedy.
REV. BRYAN SIMMONS
Ellisville, Miss.

"ALL ARE GUILTY!"
... First, I am not a "nigger lover" nor have I ever gone to bat for them. I am a third generation Texan, granddaughter of slave-holders ... Mississippi's press, school authorities and church--this is indeed and indictment of them all, singly and collectively, they brought this on themselves, YOU with them! The perpetrators of this act must have felt a tacit consent to their crime ...
... We are in a changing world and as Faulkner says, "if we are to survive, we must present one unbroken front, black and white." There can be no brotherhood of God without Brotherhood of Man, which means we must take these poor, ignorant, scared and even "uppity" people by the hand and not just talk "freedom and justice" when we mean neither.
Don't straddle the fence Tom. ALL are guilty!
MRS. M. Patton
222 South Brighton St.
Dallas Texas

"REVOLTING"
... The revolting spectacle of Mississippians siding with the NAACP Communist Party and all the gigantic forces arrayed against us ... is shocking and appalling ... modern Southern people strike me as being the most cowardly people on earth. They don't have the guts or moral stamina to defend their own race ... as for resisting integration Mr. Ethridge you may as well forget that ... militant and fanatical fighters who want to "fight" in the true sense of the word have frightened and silenced those who want to save our race by Mahatma Ghandi loin-cloth methods ...
W.D.G.
Jackson Miss.

FROM NEW MEXICO
... thanks for your Sunday column. Would that every person in the United States might read it. To further prove your statements, I am sure everybody in the nation knows about Emmett Louis Till, just as they know about your Willie McGee.
But I imagine very few people know about little Joanne Pushis, the white girl you say was way-laid, beaten, assaulted and murdered by a Negro soldier in Chicago recently. I have not heard of her case until now and I read the papers more carefully than lots of people. Thank you again.
Esther L. Munsterman
Shiprock, New Mexico

"MUST KEEP CALM"
Sunday's article, "Our People Have Behaved Mighty Well" was intelligent and fair to both races. The colored citizens of Mississippi are not going to lose their heads, even if a few rowdies do. Many of my people are afraid of radicals who keep trying to get us into trouble.
Negroes have waited too long for a better life. Things are getting better right along and we are NOT going to lose what we have gained. White and Negro citizens can settle their problems without hate and fighting. Everybody must keep calm and hope for justice.
COLORED CITIZEN
Jackson, Miss

"NAACP SMEAR TACTICS"
... your "Mississippi Notebook" certainly clarifies the situation as regards to the NAACP propaganda machine. Through the lead of patriots like you and Major Sullens, others are beginning to understand more clearly the smear tactics of NAACP ...
Robert B. Patterson
Secretary, Citizen's Council
Winona, Mississippi

LADY FLATTERS US
Your article, "Our State A Target for Smear Campaign", expressed my sentiments exactly. I would like to mail it to the boy's mother if I knew her address ... of course we could never get that in Chicago's papers ... if should be published in every newspaper in the United States.
Keep up the good work and let the agitators have it right between the eyes. So many others can't.
MEETA DAVIS
Wiggins, Miss.

THANKS, MRS. WILSON
May I comment you upon the splendid article ... the sanest thing that has been written yet and I do hope it will find its way into some Northern papers. I have already sent my copy to St. Louis and know it will be of some avail there ... may we have more and equally as good.
MRS. CLIFTON WILSON
Jackson, Mississippi

A STUDENT WRITES
I am a veteran and a senior at Mississippi State College and my home is Belzoni ...
... Belzoni was the scene of a somewhat similar circumstance some time ago when a Negro "preacher" was killed in an automobile mishap ... I was not at Belzoni but have personally talked to two men, a white and a colored man, who stated they were first to arrive at the scene.
Both stated that they removed a splintered 2 by 4 board from that man's body at the place where a "shotgun" wound was supposed to have taken his life. The "preacher" was then taken to a Negro doctor who, with the aid of a number of assistants, all Negroes, examined the corpse in seclusion, it is understood. After making the examination in private the Negro doctor, opening his examining room and holding some buckshot in his hand, announced that the preacher had been slain by a shotgun blast, so I understand.
I mention this because of our lack of vigilance, lack of knowledge and lack of estimation of our "enemy". You know as well as I that crime detection and investigation is slow and backward in parts of Mississippi, so why shouldn't the NAACP also know this and take advantage of our poor investigations and sometimes poorly qualified officials? This thing that happened at Money ... did officials allow themselves to be hoodwinked? Even with doubts that the body was Emmett Till's, they still allowed it to be sent to Chicago for immediate burial ...
Suppose the Till boy is hiding in another state, waiting for this whole thing to blow over. Are Bryant and Milam really killers? Will they be sacrificed as an appeasement or peace offering? It would please me no end if you would use your column to break this thing wide open. It is definitely up to you, the press, to keep our colors flying ...
WALLACE BLACKOOD
State College, Miss.

"CLEAR CUT CASE"
... a clear-cut case of kidnapping and murder! The men admit taking the boy from his bed. It is absurd and impossible to think the NAACP could have guessed all this was to happen and to have a body exactly the same size ready and waiting to drop in the river.
It was the Till boy they carried off and the Till body officers found in the river. I am a white Southerner, born, raised, and educated in Mississippi but I am shocked by this dastardly outrage and want to see justice done. Let's not make matters any worse by proving to

to add your section.

Newspaper Location

Leaflet © OpenStreetMap contributors

A collection of letters to the editor published in Tom Ethridge's column, reflecting public opinion in Mississippi regarding the kidnapping and murder of Emmett Till.

Citations

Genealogy (Evidence Explained)

Tom Ethridge, "Mississippi Notebook," Clarion-Ledger, September 18, 1955, p. 15; digital image, Newspapers.com (https://www.newspapers.com/article/clarion-ledger-clarion-ledger-emmett-til/203055908/ : accessed November 19, 2026).

APA 7th

Ethridge, T. (1955, September 18). Mississippi notebook. Clarion-Ledger, 15. https://www.newspapers.com/article/clarion-ledger-clarion-ledger-emmett-til/203055908/

MLA 9th

Ethridge, Tom. "Mississippi Notebook." Clarion-Ledger, 18 Sept. 1955, p. 15. Newspapers.com, https://www.newspapers.com/article/clarion-ledger-clarion-ledger-emmett-til/203055908/.

Chicago

Ethridge, Tom. "Mississippi Notebook." Clarion-Ledger, September 18, 1955, 15. https://www.newspapers.com/article/clarion-ledger-clarion-ledger-emmett-til/203055908/.

Tom EthridgeEmmett TillM. PattonMajor SullensRobert B. PattersonMeeta Davis

Tags

Civil RightsLynchingBlack Press
Contributed by Walter English